If you’re reading this, you’ve scrolled past 20 other bottles claiming to be 'hand-crafted.' Most 'craft' whiskey is designed to look good, not taste good. Our ultimate quality control test is the one that happens in your glass, not on Instagram. You’ve tracked down Pappy, you know your Stagg, so you’re here, staring at the Finger Lakes bottle, wondering if it's liquid gold or just hipster moonshine. Let’s cut to the chase. You want the real specs. The location, the history, the people, it all tells you about the juice inside. So, let’s dig into Finger Lakes Distilling and see if their story holds up.
The story doesn’t start in some dusty, moss-covered rickhouse in Kentucky. It starts with Brian McKenzie (a banker) and Thomas Earl (a winemaker) in the mid-2000s. It was less a grand dream and more a profitable accident of real estate, or maybe just a reaction to the sheer volume of Finger Lakes wine. They saw grain fields, they saw agricultural history, and they decided to open a distillery. This wasn’t a vanity project. They took it seriously, traveling to Scotland and Kentucky to pull the knowledge from the masters before launching in 2009. They became one of the first standalone distilleries in the region.
Why does the location matter? Because bourbon isn’t just a recipe. It’s a product of its environment. A chef in New Orleans cooks differently than one in Maine. Distillers are no different.
Finger Lakes Distilling went “local” before every restaurant menu was bragging about it. They operate as a New York State Farm Distillery. This isn’t just a cute title, it’s a legal requirement to use a high percentage of New York-grown raw materials. For them, it’s the entire point.
They source nearly all their corn, rye, wheat, and barley from local farmers in the Finger Lakes. This isn’t just a feel-good label story. The local terroir, the soil, the climate, the essence of the land, changes the grain’s flavor. Corn grown near Seneca Lake will taste different than corn from the industrial Midwest. That difference goes directly into the spirit and, eventually, your glass.
Every bourbon nerd knows water is critical. Kentucky distilleries famously use limestone-filtered water to remove iron and add minerals. Finger Lakes uses water from Seneca Lake, which is one of the deepest and purest of the Finger Lakes. It’s naturally filtered, clean, and cold. This pristine water is used from mashing the grains to proofing the final spirit, providing a clean, neutral canvas for the grain and the barrel to shine through, without unwanted metallic or off-flavors.
Let’s skip the candlelight and sit down in the production room. We’re going to use the whiteboard to diagram how this stuff is made. You need to know a few things about their process. Finger Lakes Distilling uses copper pot stills, which is a more traditional and labor-intensive method than the massive column stills you see from the big Kentucky players.
Pot stills are less efficient but allow for more control. The shape of the still and the distiller’s skill have a massive impact on the final product, leading to a richer, oilier, and more character-driven distillate. It’s the hard way, but it’s the right way if flavor, not volume, is the primary goal.
Now, the aging. The Finger Lakes climate is dramatic: hot, humid summers and brutally cold winters. This extreme fluctuation works the barrels hard, constantly pulling the whiskey into the oak and squeezing it back out. This cycle accelerates the aging process, imparting a ton of flavor from the oak in a relatively short time. The result is a spirit that tastes mature and complex without decades in a rickhouse.
You’ve got the backstory: ambitious guys, local grain, pure lake water, and a brutal climate. But the million-dollar question remains: how does it taste?
If we have to get descriptive, we’ll keep it to three words: Bold. Corn. Heat. Everything else is your problem. The beauty and frustration of hunting new bourbons is that what you taste is yours alone.
This is exactly why an app like OAKR is so essential for the modern bourbon enthusiast. It’s like having a team of expert tasters in your pocket. OAKR aggregates tasting notes from blind panel reviews to build a comprehensive flavor profile for hundreds of spirits (and growing quickly). Instead of relying on a single review or the marketing nonsense on the back of the bottle, you get a data-driven look at what flavors are most prominent.
You can use OAKR to explore the profile of Finger Lakes Distilling’s McKenzie Bourbon. See if its notes of cherry, vanilla, and spice, born from that local grain and dynamic aging, match what you’re looking for. The app helps you cut through the noise and get personalized recommendations based on your unique flavor preferences. It’s the smartest way to discover if the Finger Lakes Distilling history and process translate into a bourbon you’ll actually love.
So, the next time you see that bottle on the shelf, you’ll know the story behind it. It’s a story of place, passion, and a healthy dose of risk. And that’s a story worth tasting.
Login to OAKR for spirit profile flavor data, create your own lists and customize your palate to get custom somm recommendations on whiskey you’ll love.
