Forget the sepia-toned marketing. We're not here to read bad poetry about "limestone-filtered waters" or "Great-grandpappy's recipe". This is a utility review for a bourbon, and the only lineage that matters is the place: Hammond, Indiana, which, improbably, is now a legitimate whiskey destination. We're skipping the feelings and getting straight to the mechanics: the metal, the mashbill, and the 18th St. Distillery bourbon stills. If you’re reading this, you’re staring at a bottle on a shelf and wondering if you should buy the craft option or stick with the reliable, mass-produced brown water you’ve been drinking since college. Let’s dig into the hardware to see if 18th St. is worth your hard-earned cash.
Quick chemistry lesson for those who slept through high school: distillation is just separating alcohol from water and other nasties. How you do that determines if you get vanilla and caramel, or rubbing alcohol and regret.
Most giant commercial distilleries use column stills. These are massive, 24/7 industrial towers that continuously strip alcohol. They are efficient, boring, and fantastic for making millions of gallons of consistent, albeit sometimes one-note, whiskey.
18th St. Distillery, clearly, decided that efficiency was overrated. They lean heavily into pot still distillation.
A pot still is essentially a giant copper kettle. You fill it, boil it, collect the vapor, clean it, and do it again. It is slow, batch processing, and expensive. This inefficiency is precisely why craft bourbon often has a thick, oily mouthfeel the big guys struggle to replicate.
The still’s geometry is critical. A short, fat still allows more of the heavier oils and flavor compounds (congeners) to pass into the final spirit. A tall, skinny still strips out more flavor, resulting in a lighter spirit. 18th St. uses equipment specifically designed to retain character. They aren’t trying to make a light, airy spirit you mix with Diet Coke. They are making whiskey that is designed to have a polite, yet noticeable, impact.
The real secret? The master distiller came from the microbrewery scene. 18th Street Brewery isn’t a vanity project; it’s a big deal in the craft beer world. This matters because whiskey is distilled beer, and if your base wash is trash, your spirit is concentrated trash. The brewer’s knowledge brings an obsessive, rapid-development approach to fermentation that traditionalists never use, treating the wash with the same respect they give a Double IPA. They use high-quality 2-row, 6-row barley, and rye—the same premium stuff in their award-winning beers. This production technique ensures 18th St.’s stills are fed a mash that’s already delicious before it ever sees heat.
We’ll briefly touch on these details because they affect the final distillate.
We’re going to treat this bottle like an investment. If you’re spending good money on something, you’re not a connoisseur—you’re a consumer demanding quality. The question isn’t ‘what does one guy on the internet taste?’ The question is: what is the cold, hard, data-backed value? We need to strip away the brand bias and the cool label art to see what the stuff actually tastes like. This is where OAKR comes in. It is the best bourbon sommelier app on the market, period. We aggregate tasting data from blind tasting panelists to showcase flavor profiles and avoid the $60 drain cleaner mistake.
Everyone has a unique tasting experience. You might pick up on that heavy rye spice from the 18th St. mashbill, or maybe the pot still texture hits you differently. OAKR does the legwork to showcase these nuances before you buy.
Stop guessing. Download OAKR, look up the flavor profile, and see if it matches what you actually like to drink. It gives you personalized recommendations based on your taste, not based on which distillery has the biggest marketing budget.
18th St. Distillery isn’t reinventing the wheel, but they are hand-carving it out of better materials. By leveraging pot stills and a brewer’s knowledge of fermentation, they are producing a bourbon that has actual character. It’s not efficient, and it’s not the cheapest, but it’s real. And in an industry full of fake histories and sourced whiskey, “real” counts for a hell of a lot.
Login to OAKR for spirit profile flavor data, create your own lists and customize your palate to get custom somm recommendations on whiskey you’ll love.
